• Response
• Favorite
• Comments
• Share
• Flag

American Idol - Final Set of 12

• original
• responses (0)

1. 1

   Love It Hate It

   Von Smith

   "You're All I Need to Get By" -- Marvin Gaye

    

   Randy: "This is the way to kick off the show."
   Kara: "You're coming into your own... you're feeling more comfortable."
   Paula: "America's gonna remember you."
   Simon: "You remind me of Clay Aiken"

    

    

   Wife: "Mediocre at best."

2. 2

   Love It Hate It

   Taylor Vaifanua

   "If I Ain't Got You" -- Alicia Keys

    

   Kara: "You had some issues... but you've got talent."
   Paula: "I just wish you would've taken that chance [to show us something new]."
   Simon: "My problem was, I genuinely couldn't remember you."
   Randy: "You got a great voice... the problem is, you didn't say anything about you."

    

    

   Wife: "Kinda bland and boring."

3. 3

   Love It Hate It

   Alex Wagner-Trugman

   "That's Why They Call It The Blues" -- Elton John

    

   Paula: "You are certainly entertaining."
   Simon: "You're like a little hamster trying to be a tiger."
   Randy: "It definitely was kinda crazy in a buck-wild kinda way."
   Kara: "You can't pay for that kinda choreography."

    

    

   Wife: "It's unfortunate his face is smashed up like that."

4. 4

   Love It Hate It

   Arianna Afsar

   "The Winner Takes It All" -- ABBA

    

   Simon: "It was a huge, huge mistake."
   Randy: "It's really not the song I would've chose for you to sing."
   Kara: "It was dark... it was kinda depressing... not you as a person."
   Paula: "You had some bright moments in the song."

    

    

   Wife: "WTF?!"

5. 5

   Love It Hate It

   Ju'Not Joyner

   "Hey There Delilah" -- Plain White T's

    

   Randy: "Dude, I loved it."
   Kara: "I like your spin on that song... very smooth."
   Paula: "Your liberties that you took paid off."
   Simon: "That was actually better than I thought it was gonna be."

    

    

   Wife: "Too slow and boring!"

6. 6

   Love It Hate It

   Kristen McNamara

   "Give Me One Reason" -- Tracy Chapman

    

   Kara: "You know, you are a great singer."
   Paula: "This song was a little more safe you."
   Simon: "I'm slightly puzzled about you... I don't think you're entirely comfortable."
   Randy: "You tried to do too much with [the song]."

    

    

   Wife: "She looks like Jamie Pressley and Barbie's love-child."

7. 7

   Love It Hate It

   Nathaniel Marshall

   "I'd Do Anything for Love" -- Meatloaf

    

   Simon: "Some people would probably quite like that... the minority."
   Randy: "I'm just curious about that song choice."
   Kara: "You've gotta voice... Maybe we can see another side of you."
   Paula: "This song was more of like the Boy George version of this song."

    

    

   Wife: "Ugghh."

8. 8

   Love It Hate It

   Felicia Barton

   "No One" -- Alicia Keys

    

   Paula: "You're not only gorgeous outside... your talent, your gift, is unbelievable."
   Simon: "It's a bit copycat."
   Randy: "You got something a little different from Alicia... go with that."
   Kara: "This is by far the best look... you had attitude. You had presence."

    

    

   Wife: "She's kinda hot."

9. 9

   Love It Hate It

   Scott MacIntyre

   "Mandolin Rain" -- Bruce Hornsby

    

   Randy: "The parts that were great were really, really great for me."
   Kara: "You move mountains when you step on that stage."
   Paula: "I'm so happy and glad that you made it. You're one of our finest."
   Simon: "I wasn't crazy about the song... but I have to say, Scott, you're growing on me."

    

    

   Wife: "The Greatest American Hero is an American Idol?!"

10. 10

    Love It Hate It

    Kendall Beard

    "This One's For the Girls" -- Martina McBride

     

    Kara: "You had some issues... definitely with the notes... you had some flat stuff going on."
    Paula: "You take the prize on the best outfit."
    Simon: "I think you did the right thing tonight. Halfway through, I couldn't wait for it to end, personally."
    Randy: "You told us who you were, what you were."

     

     

    Wife: "I like the dress... I don't care to ever see her again, though."

11. 11

    Love It Hate It

    Jorge Nuñez

    "Don't Let the Sun Go Down on Me" -- Elton John

     

    Paula: "You worked so hard and you sound so good."
    Simon: "You're actually a very, very good singer."
    Randy: "Accent or not... it's the vocals that matter... it was really, really good."
    Kara: "You're a singer. That's your gig."

     

     

    Wife: "I'd vote for his eyebrows."

12. 12

    Love It Hate It

    Lil Rounds

    "Be Without You" -- Mary J. Blige

     

    Simon: "I'm gonna keep this very brief. Brilliant."
    Randy: "You kept your swagger on. You didn't lose your swagger tonight."
    Kara: "You still a powerhouse."
    Paula: "You are first class."

     

     

    Wife: "Done." (5 seconds into the song.)
    Wife: "It wasn't as good as I wanted it to be." (End of the song.)

1. 

   Cy about 1 year ago

   -1

   Vote Comment Up Vote Comment Down Flag Comment as Abuse

   Reply

   Hahah lovin' the wife comments. She needs to be a judge for reals.

Add New Comment

Login to leave comments! Need an account? Register today!

1. Von Smith
2. Taylor Vaifanua
3. Alex Wagner-Trugman
4. Arianna Afsar
5. Ju'Not Joyner
6. Kristen McNamara
7. Nathaniel Marshall
8. Felicia Barton
9. Scott MacIntyre
10. Kendall Beard
11. Jorge Nuñez
12. Lil Rounds